Critique Circle: Improve Your Writing Skills in a Vibrant Writing Community

Improve your writing skills and become part of a vibrant writing community at Critique Circle. As one of the largest and longest-running writing communities on the web, Critique Circle offers a platform for writers to connect, exchange feedback, and grow their craft. By critiquing the works of others and building relationships with fellow authors, you can continuously improve your writing and receive valuable feedback on your own manuscript. With thousands of writers actively participating on the site and a wealth of resources, Critique Circle is the perfect place to refine your writing skills and connect with like-minded individuals who share your passion for storytelling. Join now and become a part of this thriving community.

What is Critique Circle?

Critique Circle is a vibrant and welcoming online writing community that aims to help writers improve their writing skills. It is one of the largest and longest-running writing communities on the web. Whether you are an aspiring writer or a seasoned author, Critique Circle offers a platform for you to connect with other writers, receive constructive feedback on your work, and engage in discussions about writing.

Sign up and log in

To join Critique Circle, all you need to do is sign up for free. Simply provide your email address and create a username and password. Once you have signed up, you can log in to your account and start exploring the various features and opportunities that Critique Circle has to offer.

A vibrant writing community

Critique Circle prides itself on having a vibrant and diverse community of writers. Thousands of writers from all over the world come together on this platform to share their work, give feedback, and support each other. The community is filled with individuals who are passionate about writing and eager to improve their skills. By being a part of this community, you can tap into the collective knowledge and experiences of fellow writers.

Reciprocal critiquing

One of the unique aspects of Critique Circle is its emphasis on reciprocity. The platform operates on the principle of “crit for crit,” which means that in order to receive critiques on your own work, you must first provide critiques for others. This system ensures that members actively contribute to the community by giving back and supporting their fellow writers. By critiquing the stories of others, you not only improve your own critiquing skills but also build relationships with other authors who can help you with your own manuscript.

Active forums

Critique Circle offers active forums where members can engage in discussions on various writing-related topics. Whether you have questions about writing techniques, publishing, or any other aspect of the writing process, you can find a wealth of knowledge and support in these forums. It is a space to connect with like-minded individuals, share insights, and learn from one another. The forums cover a wide range of topics and cater to the diverse interests and needs of the writing community.

How it works

Critique Circle operates on a simple and effective three-step process: Crit, Submit, and Rewrite.

  1. Crit: To get started, critique a couple of stories submitted by other members to earn credits. The more critiques you provide, the more credits you earn. This system ensures that everyone in the community actively participates and benefits from the feedback process.
  2. Submit: Once you have accumulated enough credits, you can use them to submit your own story for review. This is an opportunity to receive feedback and constructive criticism from other members of the community, helping you identify areas for improvement in your writing.
  3. Rewrite: Armed with the valuable feedback you have received, you can now work on rewriting and revising your manuscript. The crits you receive help you gain fresh perspectives, identify any weaknesses in your work, and ultimately improve the quality of your writing.

By following this process, you can continuously improve your writing skills and grow as a writer with the help of the Critique Circle community.

Improve Your Writing Skills

Critique Circle provides a platform to improve your writing skills through a combination of critiquing others’ stories and submitting your own stories for review. Here’s how it works:

Critique others’ stories

By critiquing the stories submitted by other writers, you not only contribute to the community but also learn from the work of your peers. Critiquing allows you to analyze storytelling techniques, narrative structure, character development, and other elements of writing. By providing thoughtful, constructive feedback, you help fellow writers identify areas for improvement and gain a fresh perspective on their work. This process not only sharpens your critiquing skills but also enhances your own understanding of storytelling.

Submit your own story

Once you have earned enough credits through critiquing, you can submit your own story for review. This is an invaluable opportunity to receive feedback on your work from fellow writers who have diverse perspectives and experiences. The critiques you receive will highlight strengths and weaknesses in your writing, point out areas where you can improve, and offer suggestions for development. It’s a chance to refine your storytelling techniques, sharpen your prose, and enhance your overall writing skills.

Rewrite with feedback

The feedback you receive from the Critique Circle community serves as a roadmap for improving your writing. Armed with this feedback, you can embark on the process of rewriting and revising your story. By incorporating the suggestions and insights from fellow writers, you can strengthen your plot, enhance your character development, refine your prose, and address any other areas that require attention. This iterative process of rewriting with feedback allows you to continuously elevate the quality of your writing and grow as a writer.

Critique Circle: Improve Your Writing Skills in a Vibrant Writing Community


Critique Circle has garnered praise and recognition from its members over the years. Here are a few testimonials from writers who have benefited from the platform:

  • E. Madison Cawein, Wenatchee,WA. 98801 USA: “Critique Circle is my new favorite writing workshop! I might just make it my new Home Page!”
  • David Arnett, Hartlepool, England: “I find CC a brilliant place to polish my ability in writing and read really intriguing chapters from other creative people. I am relatively new to writing but with some more practice on here I am pretty hyped for entering this year’s NaNoWriMo.”
  • Keven Pirritano, CA, USA: “I first learned about Critique Circle from Writers Digest. It is the only writing forum I visit every day!”
  • Mark Dimig-Mathis, I’m from Joisey (exit 10): “Me like Critique Circle – it good! That’s how I USED to write, before joining Critique Circle. Now, thanks to the many fine members of CC, my writing is much, much ‘gooder.’ Okay, I’m still a newbie, but it’s an improvement. ;)”
  • Courtney Megaro, USA: “This is not one of those sites where you can post your writing and readers give you a ‘good job, keep up the good work!’ Critique Circle is filled with many talented writers who know what they’re talking about, and your writing will improve after that first critique.”

These testimonials highlight the positive impact Critique Circle has had on writers, both in terms of skill development and community support.

Tales from the Blog

Critique Circle has a blog that features articles written by its members, offering valuable insights and perspectives on various aspects of writing. Here are some of the newest blog posts:

I Rarely Read Fantasy

In this blog post, Douglas Phillips shares his preference for science fiction over fantasy and discusses the reasons behind it. By exploring his personal reading habits, he sheds light on the different elements that attract readers to different genres.

Science Fiction, yes. Fantasy, not so much.

Douglas Phillips delves deeper into his love for science fiction and explains why fantasy doesn’t quite resonate with him. Through anecdotes and personal experiences, he offers an intriguing perspective on the genres and the reasons behind his preference.

Literary prose and paced action

Clifford Morris explores the balance between literary prose and paced action in writing. By dissecting the elements that make up these two distinct styles, he provides insights into how writers can strike a balance and create engaging narratives.

From Chaos to Cohesion

Lulu O shares her personal journey from being a discovery writer/pantser to becoming an outliner/plotter. She discusses the benefits of embracing structure and outlines in the writing process, highlighting how it transformed her writing from chaos to cohesion.

These blog posts offer readers a glimpse into the thoughts and experiences of fellow writers, providing valuable perspectives and advice on different aspects of writing.

Frequently Asked Questions

Critique Circle understands that aspiring writers may have questions about the platform and its features. Here are answers to some commonly asked questions:

Is Critique Circle free?

Yes, Critique Circle is free to join. While there is a premium subscription available for additional features and perks, basic membership is free and allows access to the core functionalities of the platform.

When was the website started?

Critique Circle was first launched online in October 2003. It is one of the oldest writing websites and has been running continuously ever since, serving as a reliable platform for writers to connect and improve their craft.

How active is Critique Circle?

Critique Circle boasts thousands of active members who regularly engage with the platform. With a growing community and nearing one million served critiques, Critique Circle is a bustling hub for writers looking to improve their skills and connect with fellow authors.

How safe are my stories?

Stories submitted to Critique Circle are not considered “published online” and are not indexed by search engines. You have control over the accessibility of your stories and can delete them at any time. Critique Circle prioritizes the privacy and security of its members’ work.

Get Started

If you’re ready to improve your writing skills, join Critique Circle now. It’s easy and free to sign up, and you’ll be joining a supportive community of writers who are passionate about improving their craft. By participating in critiquing, submitting your own work, and engaging in discussions, you’ll find valuable feedback and opportunities to grow as a writer. Come on in, and let Critique Circle be your writing home.

Critique Circle: Improve Your Writing Skills in a Vibrant Writing Community

My Writing Pays uses Accessibility Checker to monitor our website's accessibility.